Style vs. Substance in Modern Golf Instruction

I have come to believe that the majority of modern day golf instruction is based primarily around instructor style preference. Way too much of the information being peddled is ‘form’ based vs. ‘function’ based.

In studying the top golfers of all time there are no two swings that are alike. Who is to say that Ben Hogan’s flat plane is better than Jack Nicklaus’ vertical arm move? Who is to say that Sam Snead’s slight over the top move was better than Nick Price’s drop down transition?

Tom Watson

Tom Watson

At the end of the day it all comes down to IMPACT! It is the one position in which all of the great players are decidedly similar. From Patty Berg to Lorena Ochoa and Tom Watson to Peter Thompson – all these players are almost identical at impact. If this is the case, which, trust me, it is, then the look of the swing should play less of a role in a golfer’s improvement and the focus should be more on impact.

Here are the elements of a great impact position:

  • the weight is noticeably on the front foot; 80% or more
  • the handle always leads the clubhead
  • the head remains over the ball, while the hips have shifted to the target; this creates what I refer to as body ‘curve’
  • the clubhead travels down (downswing!) into the ball; this includes fairway woods and the driver!

The next time you take a lesson make sure your teacher works towards getting you into a better position at impact. It is the only way you will start to hit better golf shots!

Leave a Reply

Gallery
18th Green The view from atop Table Mountain                               The 15th Makanyane look out point
What I'm Doing...
  • Very fall like weather in the Hamptons the last few days. Windy and highs only in the 60's. 2 weeks ago
  • Major champions this year are from USA, Northern Ireland, South Africa and Germany - it truly is a global game! 3 weeks ago
  • These two guys in the playoff are great - now let's see who wants it more. 3 weeks ago
  • More updates...

Posting tweet...

Powered by Twitter Tools